Back to Guides
CupsHistoryEnglish Football

The Magic of the FA Cup: Football's Greatest Knockout

F
Format History
2/1/2026
5 min read
The Magic of the FA Cup: Football's Greatest Knockout

The Oldest Competition in the World

Founded in 1871, the Football Association Challenge Cup (The FA Cup) is the oldest national football competition on Earth. While the Premier League is about consistency and the Champions League is about the elite, the FA Cup is about one thing: Romance. It is the only place in modern sports where the absolute bottom of the professional ladder gets a chance to kill the giants at the top.

The Open-Door Policy

What makes the FA Cup truly unique is that it is open to almost every club in the English football pyramid, from Level 1 down to Level 9. Over 700 teams enter every year.

The early rounds start in August on muddy village pitches, where part-time players dream of reaching the Third Round Proper—the moment when the Premier League and Championship "Big Boys" enter the draw. This is the moment when a team of postmen, mechanics, and teachers could be drawn to play at Old Trafford or Anfield.

The "Giant-Killing" Phenonemon

A "Giant-Killing" is when a small, underdog team defeats a massive, top-tier opponent. This is the "Magic of the Cup."

Historic Examples:

  • Hereford United 2-1 Newcastle United (1972): Perhaps the most famous of all. Hereford, a non-league side, beat the top-flight giants on a mud-soaked pitch thanks to a 30-yard screamer from Ronnie Radford.
  • Wigan Athletic 1-0 Manchester City (2013): In a modern final, Wigan—who were about to be relegated from the Premier League—beat the billionaire-backed Manchester City in the final at Wembley.
  • Sutton United vs. Coventry City (1989): Sutton, a non-league side, defeated the top-flight Coventry City, who had won the cup just two years earlier.

The Road to Wembley

The goal for every player is the final at Wembley Stadium. Winning the FA Cup at Wembley is considered one of the highest honors in the sport, regardless of a team's league standing.

Replays and the "Fairness" Debate

Historically, if a match ended in a draw, the teams would have a "replay" at the other team's stadium. For a small club, a replay at a Premier League stadium was a financial lifeline, providing enough money to sustain the club for years. However, to ease player fatigue and schedule congestion, replays have recently been abolished from the First Round Proper onward—a controversial move that many argue has weakened the "magic" for the smallest clubs.

The Cultural Impact: FA Cup Final Day

For decades, FA Cup Final Day was the biggest event in the English sporting calendar. It was the only match shown live on television all year. While the explosion of televised football has changed this, "Cup Final Day" remains a sacred tradition. The long walk down Wembley Way, the singing of "Abide With Me" before kickoff, and the sight of the captain lifting the silver trophy with its iconic ribbons are images embedded in football history.

The Most Productive Winners

  • Arsenal: The record-holders with 14 titles. They have built a special relationship with the competition, particularly under manager Arsène Wenger.
  • Manchester United: Closely following with 13 titles, having used the cup as a springboard for many of their most successful eras.

Conclusion

In an era where football is often criticized for being too corporate and too predictable, the FA Cup remains delightfully unpredictable. It is the competition where the underdog is celebrated, where the mud matters as much as the grass, and where the history of 150 years still breathes. The trophy may be silver, but the magic of the FA Cup is gold.

Share this guide

Use Data to Win

Now that you understand the stats, see them in action. Check out the best defensive teams in Europe right now.

View Defensive Stats